spanish monarchy

Spain’s former king excluded from celebrations for return to democracy

Juan Carlos said to be irritated he was not invited to event that praised his role in 1977 elections

Having made room in his diary for the event, Spain’s former monarch, King Juan Carlos is reportedly annoyed not to have been invited to a ceremony on Wednesday to commemorate the 40th anniversary of the creation of the first sitting of the country’s Congress following the death of military ruler General Francisco Franco in 1975 and the return to democracy.

Part of the commemorations held on Wednesday.
Part of the commemorations held on Wednesday.Álvaro García

The reason for Juan Carlos’s absence at the event was, according to the Royal Household, protocol: the former monarch, who abdicated in favor of his son, Felipe VI, in 2014, enjoys the status of King emeritus, and therefore it would have been an anomaly for him to attend such an important event in the presence of the reigning monarch.

A spokesman for King Felipe told EL PAÍS that when the monarch addresses Congress it is not customary for the former head of state to be present, and furthermore, it was Juan Carlos who established the principle when his son acceded to the throne.

Juan Carlos was reported to be unhappy at being excluded from an event that praised his key role in Spain’s democratic transition four decades ago and that was attended by other major figures who helped organize and participated in the general elections of 1977.

If the act had taken place in a less formal setting, there would have been no problem Royal Household spokesman

Juan Carlos had been sailing off the coast of Galicia for a few days, but had reportedly cleared the last week of June in his schedule, assuming he would be invited to the commemoration – not to steal the limelight from his son but to meet up with other key figures of the period.

The former monarch was in conversation with Ana Pastor, the speaker of Congress. She had mentioned ongoing talks with the Royal Household to find a way around protocol and thus make it possible for Juan Carlos to attend the event.

Juan Carlos did not attend his son’s proclamation in Congress three years ago, but the institutional reasons cited on that occasion pale beside the embarrassment of him not being invited to an event to commemorate events he played a central role in.

Juan Carlos I and Felipe VI in Madrid.
Juan Carlos I and Felipe VI in Madrid.Carlos Alvarez (Getty Images)

For example, the inclusion of the Communist Party, which was still illegal, in the elections of June 1977 was in large part due to the intermediary role played by Juan Carlos.

During his speech to Congress on Wednesday, King Felipe highlighted the role played by his father.

“If the act had taken place in a less formal setting, there would have been no problem,” said a spokesman for the Royal Household on Thursday. One solution that seems not to have been considered would have been the use of the so-called Tribune of Honor in Congress, which has been used for the heads of regional governments and other illustrious guests. This is where Queen Sofía and the infantas were seated during the proclamation of Felipe VI.

The explanations appear not to have convinced Juan Carlos. Sources close to the former monarch said he was shocked that invitations were even sent to the granddaughters of Dolores Ibárruri, the Communist Party leader credited with the phrase “They shall not pass” during the Civil War and who returned to Spain from exile in the Soviet Union in 1977.

English version by Nick Lyne.


More information

Archived In

Recomendaciones EL PAÍS
Recomendaciones EL PAÍS