Podemos party official tries to skirt taxman with €200,000 payment

Juan Carlos Monedero insists that he has not committed fraud The sum covers back taxes and penalties levied on earnings from Latin America

Juan Carlos Monedero, during a conference at a university business school last January.
Juan Carlos Monedero, during a conference at a university business school last January.Samuel Sánchez

Juan Carlos Monedero, the co-founder of Spain’s anti-austerity Podemos party and director of the organization’s electoral platform, voluntarily paid €200,000 in income taxes and fines on Thursday to satisfy a debt from €425,150 he earned as a consultant to the governments of Bolivia, Nicaragua, Venezuela and Ecuador, party officials announced last week.

Sources close to Podemos leader Pablo Iglesias explained that Monedero put his tax affairs in order with treasury officials through an agreement “that is more painful for him,” but that also demonstrates “there are no doubts about his willingness” to pay.

Monedero is asking that the Spanish Tax Agency reimburse him the €70,000 company tax that his consulting firm paid on the same funds in 2013.

Monedero’s earnings and the contracts he held with various leftist Latin American governments have been the center of controversy over the past few weeks after a story broke that the political science professor had made large sums of money as a consultant in Latin America but never paid income tax on the amounts to Spanish authorities.

More information
What does Podemos want?
Podemos kicks off election campaign with massive rally in Madrid
Leading parties blame meteoric rise of Podemos on corruption

“Under the law, the existence of a voluntary complimentary return implies that no tax fraud existed,” said party officials in a statement, adding that Monedero won’t have to face any new tax penalties.

Speaking at a rally last Thursday, Monedero told his supporters that he felt he was being persecuted by Finance Minister Cristóbal Montero, who publicly questioned his income and stated that his taxes had been paid.

“I am not scared of you, Montero. All my accounts are in order,” he said.

In its statement, Podemos said that before Monedero paid the penalty there had been no complaints filed against him by anyone for fraud or administrative violations with a judicial body or the Tax Agency. The party led by Pablo Iglesias maintains that Monedero has complied with all his tax obligations.

Reports published in other Spanish newspapers, El Mundo and La Vanguardia, state that the government has opened an investigation after Monedero filed a complete tax filing.

At the end of 2012, Monedero organized a company, Caja de Resistencia Motiva 2 Produccions SL, to bill Latin American government for consulting services that he offered three years before the firm existed.

Ignacio Ruiz Jarabo, who served as Tax Agency director during the past government of Prime Minister José María Aznar, said in an interview with the SER radio network that Monedero could face some “serious problems” with tax inspectors if they determine he billed governments three years after performing work for them.

Eleven days of denials

  • On January 18, internet publication El Plural reported that Juan Carlos Monedero was paid €425,150 in 2013 through a company called Caja de Resistencia Motiva 2 Produccions SL, which he created that same year. The money came from consulting fees he was awarded by four Latin American governments three years before the firm was created. He did not provide any receipts or contracts for the work, citing confidentiality laws.
  • Monedero filed a corporate tax return in Spain in 2013, which allowed him to pay €70,000, instead of an individual one, which would have seen him taxed €176,000 had he not created a company. He saved more than €100,000.
  • On January 23, Podemos secretary general Pablo Iglesias came to Monedero's defense. "He legally submitted invoices and he has perfectly complied with all his legal obligations with the Finance Ministry."
  • During a rally on Janauary 29 in Leganés, outside of Madrid, Monedero addressed Finance Minister Cristóbal Montero: "I am not afraid of you. All of my accounts are in order and I have paid my taxes."
  • On Friday, Monedero confirmed information published by two newspapers that on January 29 he paid the Tax Agency €176,000, plus a 15-percent late fee for a total of €204,000, according to Podemos party spokesmen. Monedero is now asking that Tax Agency return the €70,000 he paid in his corporate filing in 2013.

Archived In

Recomendaciones EL PAÍS
Recomendaciones EL PAÍS