Why Jon Bernthal is the perfect Hollywood tough guy: a Russian education, two model brothers and 15 broken noses

There’s an actor who has a significant role in both The Odyssey and Spider-Man: Brand New Day… and it’s not Tom Holland. Nor is it Zendaya. The pair of actors have dominated the summer cinematic scene, making the rounds at photoshoots to promote these two highly-anticipated releases. However, there’s a third person who, without garnering as much media attention, has established himself as one of the season’s must-see faces. It’s Jon Bernthal, 49, who plays the solemn Menelaus in Christopher Nolan’s film and the gruff Punisher in Destin Cretton’s superhero movie.

“I love their relationship, I love seeing it,” Bernthal confessed, while speaking about his co-stars at the premiere of The Odyssey, on July 14. “Beyond all the movie star stuff, beyond all the success that that guy has, the fact that he has that kind of relationship and that kind of support, and that he loves as hard as he does, makes me so happy, I’m just so proud of him and happy for him,” he added, speaking about Holland, whom he met more than a decade ago while auditioning for his Marvel roles.

More than 20 years in the business have given Bernthal the experience to deftly sidestep questions, even though his career is a bottomless well of juicy stories. “He’s led a really interesting life, and I find actors for whom that’s the case always are the most interesting to watch,” Matt Damon told The Hollywood Reporter, while being interviewed for the feature on Bernthal that graced its cover on July 16. “He happens to be incredibly tough, which is not often the case in Hollywood – there’s a range of characters he can play convincingly that others just can’t, because he really is the thing that other people wish they were,” Damon summarized.

The tough-guy image that characterizes most of Bernthal’s characters has been forged in countless battles both on and off the set. According to his IMDb page, he’s broken his nose 14 times in street fights and during particularly violent shoots. “You know, on Punisher, I did break it again. So [that] would be 15,” he confessed with a laugh in a 2024 interview.

In fiction, Bernthal has had his fill of throwing and taking punches in series like Daredevil, The Walking Dead and We Own This City. In the latter, in fact, he plays a corrupt cop and, as he recounted on a podcast last year, he received an unexpected punch from a trespasser who wandered onto the set during a scene about the Black Lives Matter protests.

“Now there’s this guy running at me. I’m like, ‘Who’s this [fucking] clown?’ Sure enough, he just throws a [fucking] right hand. I felt it cut my face.” Bernthal immediately swung back. “And I just figured, ‘alright, If he’s gonna take a swing at me, I’m gonna take a swing at him…’ so I just like, wabow, and I hit him with this right hand,” he explained.

In real life, the actor hasn’t shied away from trouble, either. Bernthal is the middle of three brothers. His eldest sibling, Tom, is the founder and former CEO of the consulting firm Kelton Global, as well as the husband of former Facebook COO Sheryl Sandberg. His youngest brother, Nicholas, is an orthopedic oncologist and a professor at UCLA. Jon, as he told The Guardian in a 2022 interview, was the black sheep of the family, testing his parents in “every single possible way.” At the age of eight, he was caught smuggling copies of Playboy at summer camp. He almost got expelled from school and was always getting into fights.

“I made a lot of mistakes in my life and I was headed down quite a few roads that I probably shouldn’t have been able to come back from. That being said, my entire life, I grew up with an infrastructure and a family around me that loved me and supported me. There’s so many folks who don’t have that,” he told the British newspaper.

Bernthal grew up in an affluent suburb of Washington, D.C., but soon began hanging out with friends from rougher neighborhoods. In high school, he was mugged on the subway and had his nose broken for the second time. After that, he started to learn self-defense, training in taekwondo and boxing. “I think Jon was really drawn to the excitement and pure testosterone-fueled like, ‘Me and my boys are going out and this night could turn any way,’” his brother Nick told The New York Times in 2025.

“I always wanted to be around the most dangerous people,” the actor himself confessed to the same newspaper, back in 2022. “I always wanted to explore the most dangerous nooks and crannies of my city and see how far I could get away with things. And when you have brothers who are super high-achieving, I think maybe I was pushing the boundaries, because I wanted to see, ‘would they still love me if I did this?”.

The son of a renowned lawyer, he avoided jail time on more than one occasion. His most well-known incident occurred in 2009, while walking his pit bull on Venice Beach. As he told Esquire in 2018, a drunk man started shouting and grabbing at the dog, and Bernthal reacted. The man and some of his friends then began following the actor home, ignoring his warnings to back off.

“Bernthal wheeled [around] and punched him in the face. The man was out before his head hit the pavement,” Esquire detailed. An hour later, he was in jail. “If that guy doesn’t wake up, you’re going away for life,” the officers told him. Luckily, the man woke up. Bernthal received a three-year suspended sentence and was hit with a $2 million civil suit, which was eventually settled out of court.

“I would like to be able to tell you that I was horrified I might’ve just taken someone’s life, but the scary thing is that was not even a weird night for me back then,” he told The New York Times last year.

Despite his boxer-like appearance, Bernthal decided to channel his six-foot-one energy into baseball. He was good enough to receive a scholarship to Skidmore College, in Saratoga Springs, New York. There, his future was decided by chance… or, rather, by mistake. He inadvertently signed up for an advanced theater class, instead of an easy course to earn credits. But after Bernthal gave a heartbreaking improvisation – about a son whose mother gifts him a baseball glove on her deathbed – the professor was so moved that she gave him the role of Roger Chillingworth in the school production of The Scarlet Letter. And he loved it.

“I do know that, before I found acting, I was really lost and everybody was really worried about me. I had never poured in all of my energy and grit and determination into anything, but when I found acting, I poured it all into that and it served me,” he revealed to the newspaper.

The same teacher who discovered his talent advised him to audition for the Moscow Art Theatre, and Bernthal nailed it. He moved to the Russian capital in 1999, shortly before the outbreak of the Second Chechen War and Vladimir Putin’s rise to power. The bad boy from Washington, D.C., suddenly discovered what a truly lawless city was like.

“I never saw such rampant cruelty and complete, brazen disinterest in people’s feelings,” he recalled in 2025. In Moscow, he continued playing baseball and was signed as a catcher for a team in the Russian semi-professional league. “That’s where all of the greatest baseball players flock to, man. It’s totally under the radar,” he joked on Conan O’Brien’s show, back in 2014.

Even so, it was in acting classes that he truly honed his skills. The New York Times described that period of his life as resembling “a military school.”

“His teachers had staged unsanctioned plays during the Soviet era, risking imprisonment and the gulag. Theater represented real danger – real anarchy. It was something they were willing to die for.”

The training included daily exercises in acting and focus, as well as in acrobatics and ballet. Students who didn’t measure up were systematically expelled from the program. “It was a very intense, masculine way of approaching art that I could really vibe with,” Bernthal noted. In 2000, his performance in Chekhov’s The Bear attracted the attention of a Harvard talent scout. And, two years later, he graduated with a Master of Fine Arts degree from the prestigious university.

Interestingly, his brief, yet essential role in a series with the same name as the Russian playwright’s work – The Bear – earned Bernthal an Emmy for Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series, in 2024.

“There are no words for how grateful I am for The Bear. I’m grateful to be a part of it, grateful that I get to watch it, and just plain grateful that it exists. It’s personal without being precious, sacred without being sanctimonious, and elegant without being indulgent,” he wrote on his Instagram profile – to his five million followers – after learning the news.

“If you talk to folks who knew me as a young man, they would tell you: ‘It was not gonna work out for this guy.’ But I found this thing (acting). I’ve worked on it like crazy; I put everything I have into it. And it really is a dream – I’m living a dream,” Bernthal admitted to The Guardian.

He says there’s no chance of falling back into his old habits. After the incident that nearly cost him his freedom in 2009, the actor went to therapy and attended anger management classes. In interviews, he often mentions how eternally grateful he is to the drama teacher who changed his life. But he also always remembers how his wife, Erin Angle, helped him get back on track.

The actor and the nurse have been married since 2010 and have three children together: 15-year-old Henry, 13-year-old Billy and 11-year-old Adeline. “My life consists of my wife, my kids and my work. I’m able to take all of that energy, and all of that danger and throw it all into my work. And I’m so grateful for that, because I know how badly it could have gone. I can literally say, with my head held high: ‘I’m safe from that now.’ I know how to create danger, but I know how to do it in a totally healthy way,” he revealed to the British paper.

Among his upcoming projects, only one title is listed, still in pre-production: the action comedy Snow Ponies. One synopsis starts off with the following words: “A crew of seven hardened men…” And no further reading is needed to know that this role fits Bernthal perfectly.

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get more English-language news coverage from EL PAÍS USA Edition