An endless pile of unpaid invoices
Local treasurers explain how they are coping with their share of 37 billion euros of debt
In early July, Spain's cities and towns were more than 37 billion euros in the red. This is the highest level of total municipal debt on record, and it comes at the worst possible time, when revenue has plummeted. The situation is so dire that some local corporations have started to fire personnel; others have been withholding payment to their providers for years; some have seen streets and squares seized over payment defaults; and then there are those that have come up with extravagant savings measures, such as turning off the traffic lights at night.
What follows are the stories of five local treasurers; people who are on the frontline of the crisis and are forced to deal with multiple day-to-day needs with a shocking lack of funds.
José Manuel Pardal. Vilagarcía de Arousa (Pontevedra). It is 8am when Vilagarcía's treasurer walks up the steps of the town hall, taking himself and his briefcase to the municipal offices. Today, José Manuel Pardal hopes to make progress on the restructuring plan commissioned by Mayor Tomás Fole of the Popular Party (PP). This document will be the financial blueprint against the crisis over the next four years. The conservative party, which rules this town of nearly 38,000 residents, puts the deficit at nearly four million euros.
Pardal spends two hours a day dealing with the battered finances that the PP found itself with when it took over after 20 years of leftist rule by the Socialists and the nationalists of BNG. The providers alone are owed nearly seven million euros. "I'm okay with it, by being methodical and trying to keep everything under control, one bit at a time," he says. The main problem is how to pay 500 overdue bills. A 1.2-million-euro loan from the Spanish credit institution ICO will allow the town to pay off around 10 percent of the amount it owes. "We'll see how we deal with the rest," says Pardal, looking concerned.
The city official has words of praise for the municipal staff, despite the fact that there is a glut of workers: 400 employees whose salaries take up fully half of the town's 30-million-euro budget. "I can't complain because they're all doing their job and they're very committed." Still, the city is planning a labor force adjustment plan. "Well, yes, but who is free of that threat these days? You're not, either here or anywhere else."
Iban López. Santurtzi (Bizkaia). "This term of office is ruled by imagination, not money ? there is none," says Iban López, 41, who is the head of the treasury department at Santurtzi, home to 47,000 people. This town, 15 kilometers from Bilbao, has been ruled by the Basque Nationalist Party (PNV) since May, and austerity has been the norm ever since. "We have to cut back wherever we can," he says. Not long ago, city officials considered changing all the light bulbs on the streets. "In boom times, this would have been carried out without thinking twice about it. Not now. We thought about it, we did the math. We only made the change where we saw that it would be worth it because the new lights would consume 25 percent less electricity."
López boasts about being a "politician on the street." As soon as he can, he leaves the office and seeks direct contact with people. "Some people are very angry and they say all kinds of things to me. I listen to them and we talk. I always try to talk. If someone comes to my office and says he cannot pay property tax because of the current situation, I try to find a solution, like paying in installments. I also try to be punctual in my payments to workshops or businesses that work for us and are going through difficult times," he says. Despite everything, López feels that "things are not that bad" at his corporation.
Javier Serralvo. Vila-real (Castellón). There is always a green folder sitting on his table, with a label that says "Bills pending signature." When he became the head of the local treasury department in Vila-real, population 51,367, Javier Serralvo found that the town owed 4.5 million euros in bills. More invoices came in over the next month, bringing the total up to nearly six million, over 15 percent of the local budget. Now, for about 12 hours a day, Serralvo tries to put some order in the municipal accounts. And it's not just the bills ? it's also the money owed to the city by the regional government of Valencia and the 20-million-euro loan that the former government team took out and which must now be paid off.
Serralvo, a Socialist, spends many hours at his desk. And it's almost better that way, because every time he ventures out, someone comes up to him to ask when he's going to be paid. The first thing he did when he was appointed to the post was to review all pending payments, draw up a plan and suggest a change to the budget to pay off around 800,000 euros between September and October. "The rest we will pay by April 30," he asserts. And there is another issue. There are over one million euros in bills that he is carefully poring over, because many of them were sent by Lubasa and Piaf, two of the companies under investigation in a case of alleged illegal financing by the PP. "We are finding invoices for work that was never done," says Serralvo.
Carlos Esgueva. Montgat (Barcelona). "My day is all about routine, it's not very interesting," warns Carlos Esgueva, the treasurer of Montgat, population 10,500. But nothing could be further from the truth. Esgueva, an economist and financial analyst by trade, worked for years in multinational firms. His job there was to find investors. And that is exactly what he is trying to do now. His main concern is the amount of red tape and the organizational defects of his new workplace. "It's like managing chaos," he admits. The current debt level, estimated at 358,000 euros, is not a major concern for a town ? run by the center-right nationalists of CiU ? that enjoys a budget of 11 million euros. But it could become a problem in the near future, as the town will have to ask for a one-million-euro loan to deal with two expropriations.
On one end of his desk, around 150 files pile up every day ? bills, transfer orders and the like. Esgueva spends a couple of hours a day reviewing them. "What are they, why are they being paid and is there a way of doing this cheaper?" is his slogan every time he opens one of the files.
Diego Galindo Saeta. Mengíbar (Jaén). At age 33, Diego Galindo Saeta is taking his first steps in local politics as the treasurer of Mengíbar, a town of 9,780 souls in the province of Jaén. "The worst part is the impotence you feel when you have to tell providers that there's no money and that they will have to wait," says this Socialist who is not a full-time public employee, and who combines his position with his regular job as a computer programmer.
Galindo, interestingly, is also in charge of the local fiestas. "The treasurer told the fiesta chief that there was no money," he jokes. He solved the problem by reducing the fiesta budget by half and using a lot of imagination to draw up the program. "We favored cheap and local."
The PP politician allegedly bought off with a Porsche
An undercover investigation into a Galician businessman for alleged environmental crimes has led authorities to a regional Popular Party (PP) lawmaker who reportedly received a Porsche from the main suspect and discussed payoffs in exchange for his help in winning public contracts.
PP deputy Javier Escribano stepped down from his post on Saturday after he was named as a co-defendant. Authorities say they have taped dozens of phone conservations between Fermín Duarte, the owner of Manmer SL, and Escribano. Duarte was arrested after an investigating judge unsealed the case on Thursday.
This latest investigation in Galicia comes less than three weeks before the general elections. The name of A Coruña Mayor Carlos Negreira, who is also the PP provincial leader, has also been dragged into the affair after he was mentioned in one phone tap as having tipped off Escribano about the inquiry.
On Monday Pablo García, the Socialist Party leader in Galicia, called on regional premier Alberto Nuñez Feijóo, also of the PP, to appear in parliament to explain "the negotiations that took place" that allowed Escribano to "end up with a Porsche."
Feijóo said that the PP has already said all it was going to about the case, adding that his party acted swiftly in accepting Escribano's resignation. "There are other people out there that if they were to join the PP they would never be included in any election slate or appointed to any office," he said, in a blind reference to Socialist members.
Carlos Aymerich, the Galician Nationalist Bloc (BNG) parliamentary leader, has asked Negreira "to reveal all he knows" about the bribery and influence-peddling accusations in his city. Speaking to reporters, the A Coruña mayor said he had nothing to add, explaining that he only found out about the investigation when Escribano handed in his resignation.
Justice Minister Francisco Caamaño refused to comment about Escribano's resignation, given that the case is still under investigation.
Authorities tapped dozens of cellphone conversations that not only lend credence to the claim that Escribano received a Porsche but also include discussion of illegal payoffs.
The undercover operation began when the Galician Grain Association (AGA) filed a complaint against Duarte for allegedly trying to sell residues that were potentially harmful to the environment to construction companies.
Environmental prosecutors dropped the case after determining that Duarte had not committed any crime. Instead, they prohibited the businessman from selling certain types of materials and ordered him to conduct an analysis every time he mixed them with potentially harmful substances.
Duarte ignored the prosecution's order and began selling suspicious concrete, which brought on another AGA complaint. That was when an investigating judge in Ferol ordered Duarte's cellphone tapped.
In one conversation — copies of the transcripts have been obtained by EL PAÍS — Escribano is heard promising to help Duarte and his Manmer firm to obtain contracts so that his materials are bought by the regional government for public projects.
In another tapped call, Escribano tells a female friend that Negreira alerted him that he was being investigated for corruption, that his phone was tapped and that an EL PAÍS reporter was preparing to write a story about the investigation. At that time, the newspaper had no indications of the judicial case.
After that conversation, Escribano stopped using his cellphone. Several months earlier, Duarte told one family member in another phone call: "I had to give a Porsche to a PP politician. You don't know anything about this; this is the way things run around here. And if I was him I would do the same thing."
Police discovered that Escribano received the car, and then put it under the name of a family member over the age of 60 and sold it through the internet.
Tu suscripción se está usando en otro dispositivo
¿Quieres añadir otro usuario a tu suscripción?
Si continúas leyendo en este dispositivo, no se podrá leer en el otro.
FlechaTu suscripción se está usando en otro dispositivo y solo puedes acceder a EL PAÍS desde un dispositivo a la vez.
Si quieres compartir tu cuenta, cambia tu suscripción a la modalidad Premium, así podrás añadir otro usuario. Cada uno accederá con su propia cuenta de email, lo que os permitirá personalizar vuestra experiencia en EL PAÍS.
En el caso de no saber quién está usando tu cuenta, te recomendamos cambiar tu contraseña aquí.
Si decides continuar compartiendo tu cuenta, este mensaje se mostrará en tu dispositivo y en el de la otra persona que está usando tu cuenta de forma indefinida, afectando a tu experiencia de lectura. Puedes consultar aquí los términos y condiciones de la suscripción digital.