US JUSTICE SYSTEM

State of Florida will ask for the death penalty at Pablo Ibar retrial

The Spaniard of Basque descent has already spent 16 years on death row, after a conviction in the 1990s for a triple-homicide

Pablo Ibar in a file photo.
Pablo Ibar in a file photo.EFE

More information

The State of Florida has announced its decision to ask for capital punishment for Pablo Ibar, despite the Florida Supreme Court having vacated a death penalty sentence from the year 2000 and ordered a new trial.

Ibar, a Spanish citizen of Basque descent, was convicted of a 1994 triple homicide of a nightclub owner and two models. He has already served 22 years in prison, 16 of them on death row

Andrés Krakenberger, a spokesman for the Pablo Ibar Association Against the Death Penalty, told reporters at a news conference on Tuesday that the defense had received the state’s notification. He said the decision was “predictable,” though it has caused “profound disappointment,” given that the prosecution is pressing charges against someone who has “clear proof of his innocence.”

A spokesman for Ibar claims that he was wrongly convicted and has already had to serve 16 years on death row

Krakenberger said Ibar was wrongly convicted and has already had to serve 16 years on death row, while the Florida Supreme Court agrees that the “scant” evidence against him is “weak.”

The court vacated the conviction in February saying: “Ibar’s DNA was not found on a blue t-shirt recovered from the crime scene that was allegedly used to partially cover the face of the perpetrator, whom the state claimed to have been Ibar. [...] Ibar never confessed to the crime as he steadfastly proclaimed his innocence [and] presented an alibi as to his whereabouts.”

The spokesman criticized “the coldness” of the notification the defense received. Krakenberger said it shows that capital punishment is seen as a “procedure” in the United States despite the fact that it is “cruel, inhumane and degrading” and “has no place in the 21st century.”

Sign up for our newsletter

EL PAÍS English Edition has launched a weekly newsletter. Sign up today to receive a selection of our best stories in your inbox every Saturday morning. For full details about how to subscribe, click here.

Krakenberger told reporters that Ibar, who was transferred from death row to a county jail earlier this month, received the news with “a certain resignation,” though he said, speaking broadly, that he was in good spirits because his situation “has improved.”

Ibar’s defense team needs $1.3 million to mount their case. They still need to raise $590,000. The defendant has received $50,000 for his legal fees from the Basque Country government, regional organizations and private individuals who have donated to the cause through the association’s website.

English version by Dyane Jean François.

More information